Matanzas On The Bay in Fort Myers Beach has been a local favorite since 1984, offering a true taste of Southwest Florida’s laid-back lifestyle. Located right on the water, the restaurant combines fresh seafood, scenic bay views, and a relaxed island atmosphere.
The menu features a wide variety of fresh seafood, classic favorites, and even some of the best pizza on the island. With both indoor and outdoor seating, guests can enjoy the perfect setting for any occasion.
The second-floor bar, known as Petey’s Upper Deck, is famous for its lively atmosphere, nightly entertainment, and reputation for serving some of the best pizza on the island. It’s a great spot to enjoy drinks, music, and waterfront views.
The atmosphere is casual, welcoming, and coastal. Matanzas On The Bay attracts families, couples, boaters, and groups of friends looking for a relaxed dining experience with great food and entertainment.
Located within the Matanzas Bayside Inn, the restaurant is easily accessible by both car and boat. Its prime waterfront setting and long-standing reputation make it one of the top dining destinations on Fort Myers Beach.
Hours: Open daily from 11 AM to 10 PM
Bedroom: 3 (2 King, 2 Single Beds)
Bathroom: 2 1/2
